Papa John's had not previously offered any flavored crusts. In 2017, the company played a prank on garlic sauce enthusiasts ...

As a result, Papa John's made the gallons of garlic sauce a reality. A gallon costs $20. It was available only in certain cities. We had some garlic sauce fans of our own try it on a few different ...

And for Papa John's loyalists, one of those infamous add-ons is the chain's garlic sauce. This stuff is super creamy and packed with craveable garlic flavor, and may seem perfect as-is.